Should my next laptop be a Mac or Windows 7 system?

I am currently using a 3 year old Windows XP laptop and am planning to buy a new laptop. Could you please suggest to me whether I should go for a Mac or a Windows 7 laptop? I would really appreciate your analysis.

- Aman

The "what should I buy" question is getting more complicated with each advance made by both Apple and Microsoft.

Apple's commercials seem to present compelling reasons to switch, but no 30 second commercial can really cover all the issues in making this very significant decision.

At the end of the day, the actual operating system (Windows 7 or Mac OS X) is less significant than the applications that you plan to run on the computer, so that's where everyone struggling with this decision should start.

Since you're coming from the Windows world, one of the first questions to ask yourself is are you prepared to re-buy some or all of your primary productivity programs such as word processors, spreadsheets, photo editing, etc?

If you already own Microsoft Office, Photoshop Elements, Quicken for Windows or a number of other common Windows programs, you will have to add the cost of purchasing the Mac versions to your calculations.

Additionally, you will need to be prepared for the learning curve of switching to new programs and operating systems (not really that big of a deal if you possess a little patience).

If you don't have any legacy software to consider, you don't do much more than surf the web and shoot off e-mails or you're starting over anyway, then these issues are irrelevant.

If you have existing printers, scanners, digital cameras or other hardware peripherals that you want to continue using, you must determine if they are Mac compatible as well. If not, you may also end up replacing some items that are still working but not compatible in the Mac OS.

The next consideration is whether your computer (and the associated programs and data files) need to interact with other computers, such as your work computer or other computers on your home network.

If, for instance, your company requires you to connect to the office network through a VPN (Virtual Private Network), you must ensure that your IT department supports a remote Mac on the corporate network.

If you need to constantly exchange files with other Windows users, you need to make sure that your new Mac OS programs can exchange files without a lot of complications or conversions (most common files like word processing and spreadsheets are no problem).

Another major consideration is your circle of support. Most of us call a friend or family member when we encounter a computer issue, so if you have others you rely upon to help you, make sure they can help you with the Mac before you make the switch (or be comfortable that all of your questions can be addressed by Apples various support mechanisms, which generally receive high ratings).

One of the main drivers for switchers is the very effective messaging about how the Mac OS is safer than Windows, which at this point in time is absolutely true.

The primary reason the Mac OS is safer is because the number of users worldwide is still in the 5%-6% range while Windows is used by over 90% of users ( details at http://bit.ly/1HbdQx ). Pirated copies of Windows are also widely in use around the world and tend to be missing security updates, making them easy targets.

If you were a cyber-criminal and wanted to exploit others, why would you waste time on the small group when your chances of snaring someone are exponentially higher by targeting the majority? Security experts are warning that an acceleration in exploiting Mac vulnerabilities is forthcoming as the market share grows - http://bit.ly/dRP9l .

Additionally, we are seeing more sophisticated attacks these days that don't rely so much on the operating system, but target browsers (Internet Explorer, Firefox, Safari, etc.) which can be exploited on any platform.

Fooling users into giving up information (phishing scams) isn't specific to operating systems either, so be sure to manage your expectations on the constantly evolving safety issues if you decide to switch.

The Apple commercials have done a great job in planting the "should I switch?" question in peoples minds, but now you know how complex this question really is, so do your homework before deciding!
Link to the original content.

Comments
Ken - I think the omission of the fact that current generation Macs can run Windows (XP, Vista, Win7) natively. This addresses all of your incompatibility points, networking issues, legacy software, and so on. It's like having two computers in one. I use the Windows configuration any time I want to run a PC-only or way-better-on-PC software... I play to the strengths of the software and platform on a case-by-case basis. Having a Mac that runs both Mac and Windows is like having your cake and eating it too. Please consider issuing an editorial update or follow-up post that addresses this issue. Thanks.
# Posted By option8films | 11/25/09 11:39 AM
Ken, I'm not really sure how it is that you are supposed to be qualified to answer this question when it is blatantly obvious that you nothing whatsoever about Apple computers. I would have thought that you would have done some research into this subject before posting a video on CNN showing just how completely uninformed you are.
The current generation of Apple computers, desktops and laptops, run "Intel" processors. This gives them the ability to run both Apple and Windows operating systems. You can run both operating systems, Apple and Windows, simultaneously and switch back and forth as you please. All of the old compatibility problems that Apple computers once had are now a thing of the past. That means that both Apple compatible and Windows compatible software can be used on the same platform. With Apple computers you get the best of both worlds. Regardless of which operating system you prefer you can run it on Apple hardware.

Do the public a favor and go find yourself a job that doesn't require actually knowing anything.
It would have taken you less than 5 minutes to find this information if you were actually serious.
You're a joke.
# Posted By Damon Kennedy | 11/26/09 4:01 AM
First, I agree with the previous posters that the Mac/PC argument is mute when you realize that Mac can run both OS's (yes, there are cost issues, but the question did not address that). Let's go with your assumption and say that the individual intends to switch OS's if he goes to the Mac (which is likely), many of the issue you raised about going from XP to OS X also apply to going from XP to Win 7 - which is the OS that will likely come with a new system. Peripheral compatibility and legacy software will also be an issue on a new system since we know that old drivers may not work on Win 7 and Win 7 has an XP mode since there is older software that will not work on Win 7 natively. Furthermore, the issue of a learning curve is also unfairly presented since I would argue that going from XP to Win 7 has as much (if not more) of a learning curve than going from XP to OS X. I've gone from XP to OS X and from XP to Vista (I'll argue synonymous with Win 7 from a learning standpoint) and I had an easier time learning OS X than I did Vista. As for your "support system" argument, i.e., who you call for help. When you refer to your friends/family, again the comparison is not whether your potential helpers use Window, but do they use Win 7 (when my dad calls, I need to see the same OS he's using), Window as a whole has 90% of the market, Win 7 does not, so your late night helpful friend may not be on the same OS even if he uses Windows. The bottom line, help may come from official support outlets and then the advice should be to look up objective reviews of how good the company's (Apple, HP, whomever) support service is. Finally, and most importantly, you can't dismiss the notion of the significance of the OS and the software that comes bundled. Depending on how technically savvy someone is, the functioning of the OS may matter in terms of efficiency, security (which the OS X security through obscurity argument does not hold up well when you look at objective security data), and bundled software (e.g., I may have to buy a new version of Photoshop for the Mac, but maybe iPhoto will serve my needs and it comes bundled). I usually see your videos on CNN and think you give good advice, however, this really came across as uninformed and biased, you dropped the ball on this one.
# Posted By Carlos | 11/27/09 9:12 PM
I love Mac milatants! The passion is inspiring! My perspective is based on working with lots of switchers that are not technical by nature and the most common "I wish I had known that" responses. The suggestion that the average computer user run two operating systems on the same machine illustrates the differences of perspective as that is an unrealistic solution (far too complicated). If switching to a Mac was such a breeze with no complications, the MacOS market share would be growing at a much faster pace. BTW, we run lots of Macs in our operations as well as dual OS laptops, so I understand what you are saying, but don't agree that it's a solution for our average customer, listener or viewer.

I do, however, really appreciate that you guys took the time to voice your opinions and help thicken my skin!

Cheers!

Ken
# Posted By The Data Doctor | 12/1/09 5:17 PM
Site contents copyright 2004-2012 by Data Doctors Franchise Systems Inc. All rights reserved.